"Should I do LSA or regular Google Ads?" is probably the question I get most from home service owners. The short answer is that it's rarely either/or. But the order matters, and so does knowing what each one is good at.
The one-minute difference
Local Services Ads show at the very top of Google with the Google Verified badge. You pay per lead. You don't choose keywords and you can't write the ad.
Google Search Ads show under LSA and above the map. You pay per click. You choose the keywords, write the ads and send people to a page you control.
| Local Services Ads | Google Search Ads | |
|---|---|---|
| You pay for | A lead (call, message, booking) | A click |
| Keywords | No, Google matches by category | Yes, you choose them |
| Ad copy | Built from your profile | You write it |
| Landing page | None, people call or message | Your website or landing page |
| Badge | Google Verified | None |
| Setup effort | Low to medium | Medium to high |
| Control | Limited | High |
| Best for | Calls for core services | Specific services, high-value jobs, scaling |
Where LSA wins
LSA is the easier win for most trades. You don't pay for curious clicks. A person who calls you from an LSA ad usually needs the job done soon.
It also takes less skill to run well. There's no keyword research, no negative keyword list, no landing page to build. If your reviews are strong and you answer the phone, you'll get leads.
The other quiet advantage is trust. The badge and the star rating sit right in the ad. For an emergency job, a homeowner looking at three plumbers will usually call the one with 240 reviews and the badge.
Where Google Search Ads win
Search ads give you control, and control is how you grow past a certain point.
- You choose the jobs. Want more panel upgrades and fewer outlet repairs? Bid on those keywords and write ads for them. LSA can't do that well.
- You can scale. LSA has very few spots. Once you're winning most of the leads in your area, extra budget doesn't buy more. Search has far more inventory.
- You own the landing page. A good page with your offer, photos, reviews and a form converts visitors that LSA never sees.
- More categories. Some services aren't eligible for LSA at all. Search ads have no such limit.
The trade-off is cost risk. A badly built Search campaign can waste money fast on irrelevant clicks. That's why tracking and negative keywords aren't optional extras.
What it looks like in real numbers
I can't share client cost per lead for LSA here, but I can show what the click side costs. These are top-of-page bid ranges from Google Keyword Planner for the US (October 2025 to September 2026):
| Search term | US searches per month | Top-of-page bid range |
|---|---|---|
| emergency plumber | 90,500 | $13.54 to $105.00 |
| garage door repair | 246,000 | $14.27 to $84.99 |
| water damage restoration | 90,500 | $13.80 to $90.00 |
| electrician near me | 368,000 | $5.72 to $54.00 |
| roofing contractor | 165,000 | $0.68 to $36.00 |
If you need three or four clicks to get one call, an emergency plumbing lead from Search can easily cost $150 or more. That's why I almost always start trades with LSA, where the same lead is often cheaper.
The order I set them up
For most home service and professional service businesses in the US and Canada, this is the sequence:
- Fix the basics. Google Business Profile verified and complete, reviews coming in every week, calls answered.
- Launch LSA. Pick only the job types and areas you want. Give it three or four weeks.
- Set up tracking. Call tracking and form tracking on your website, so you know where every lead comes from.
- Launch Search for your best services. Start with your highest-value jobs and emergency terms, with tight keyword lists and strong negatives.
- Add retargeting or Meta later. Only after the core is profitable.
Run LSA for volume on your core services. Use Search to go after the specific, higher-value jobs LSA can't target.
What changes now that LSA is moving into Google Ads
From August 2026 Google started moving US LSA accounts into Google Ads as pay-per-lead Performance Max campaigns, with Canada and the UK following in 2027. Billing stays per lead.
The practical upside: your LSA and Search campaigns will live in one account. That makes it much easier to compare cost per lead side by side and move budget to whatever is working. The downside is a single Target CPA for the whole LSA campaign, so keep an eye on whether Google starts favoring cheap, low-value jobs.
When I'd skip LSA
- Your category isn't eligible in your country.
- You have fewer than ten reviews. Build those first.
- Nobody can answer the phone during the day. LSA punishes missed calls.
- You only want one very specific type of job that LSA can't isolate.
In those cases I'd start with a small, tightly controlled Search campaign and a proper landing page.




